https://www.slashfilm.com/1644193/prometheus-crucial-to-ridley-scott-alien-franchise
Oh, they always come back.
Another year, another would-be contrarian defending a dully normal movie like Prometheus, Transformers, or a Star Wars prequel or something. That’s understandable to a point. Those movies were expensive, fun, and stupid– you know, enjoyable. People enjoy talking about what they enjoy. This would be fine were it not.. just… pointedly irritating to see so many champions raising the battle-ragged flag for preposterously profitable movies that everyone watched. That is, of course, the point. People who enjoyed Shakes The Clown way back in 1991 don’t bother anyone in 2024, yet advocates for widely-disliked Ehren Krueger projects never seem to go away.
There’s normally little to be said about this, but Prometheus is an interesting case. It’s a science fiction film with undeniable production skills visible onscreen, directed by a wildly inconsistent legend with masterpieces and trash alike, which precisely replicates the appeal of some elaborate genre classics. It’s worth admiring if you can admit what it truly is.
Prometheus is just Planet Of The Vampires given a proper budget and the wonderful pretensions of Forbidden Planet– not to mention a complex riff on the latter’s robot character. Mario Bava didn’t have access to the resources Metro-Goldwyn-Meyer pumped into Forbidden Planet, so he made up for it with Planet Of The Vampire’s sheer style. Under Ridley Scott, Jon Spaihts and that Lost guy combined the differing strengths of both earlier movies in a modern product.
Great! It’s fine that it’s dumb! No serious SFF fan is going into a movie expecting Stand on Zanzibar or Stars In My Pocket Like Grains Of Sand. Science Fiction films don’t have to be great or even good, they just need to scratch an itch not satisfied by the written word. Intelligent films like Primer, Gattaca, or Neptune Frost, succeeding both as SFF and as cinematic offerings, are appreciated but never expected. Yes, Prometheus accomplished what it set out to do. And yes, I’ll even admit that it was bullied unfairly– Interstellar came out two years later, just as brainless and critically beloved.
That’s the caveat concluded. People pretending that Ridley Scott’s unfocused indulgence was anything more than an enjoyable and pretty mess of a big old monster movie is dishonest. Stupid characters stumbling vaguely through an incohesive attempt at a franchise prequel plot isn’t an actual problem for Prometheus, because none of that gets in the way of its existence as entertaining schlock. If it were defended as such, all would be well. Unfortunately its apologists are full of themselves. They make hay out of its themes and attempts at deeper meaning. They’re very impressed that a movie would have themes. This seems novel to them. They say words like “mythology” and puff their feathers. That it’s nothing more than a Big Stompy Monster Message movie on par with a Godzilla flick seems to elude them. The fictional Garth Marenghi once said, “I’ve met writers who used subtext, and they were all cowards.” Prometheus tuned into this ethos fully. Enter; the only interesting character in the whole moving picture facing a metaphorical god, presenting audience-redundant information to it under the mysterious guise of an untranslated alien language, and getting his head twisted off right before a big ole slam-bang Hollywood action ending. Yes, we get it. The space jockey from the (fantastic) opening sequence was Prometheus stealing the fire of life from the other Olympians and bringing it to the world, resulting in an Age Of Humanity. Cue a very impressed reaction from everyone who somehow didn’t catch it immediately. Metaphorical layers turn the paper-thin Hostile Alien Species out to Destroy The Earth and Kill All Humans into a very intellectual exercise, you see. It’s true that this is squares with 1979’s Alien hinting at an unknowable giant corpse as belonging to some alien bomber pilot (a delicious idea from Dan O’Bannon) with the titular ‘alien’ being mere payload from his hangar bay. This also flies in the face at everything the 2012 film grandly fumbled at for its preceding runtime.
The author of the Slashfilm article at the beginning of this op-ed reaches some different conclusions. They heard Weyland mention “stealing fire” and assumed this thematic cue meant that he was the Promethean connection, no further questions to precede more shaky interpretations. Xenomorphs are metaphorically a bunch of liver-eating eagles, apparently. I suppose Weyland-Yutani’s profit margins represent the chains and the big rock. The author also cites another Slashfilm article from 2017, titled “Prometheus Is One Of The Boldest Science Fiction Films In Recent Memory.”
You might recall that– flawed as it was– Arrival had been released one year earlier. Seven years earlier, you had Gareth Edwards’ Monsters. Six years earlier, Attack The Block. Five years earlier, Chronicle. Four years, the remake of Hard To Be A God. Three years, The Signal. Two years? Ridley Scott redeemed his entire whole-ass reputation with The Martian.
10 Goddamn Cloverfield Lane was more narratively imaginative and bolder as SFF than Prometheus. The former was experimental, and the latter was expensive. Yet here we are in 2024, with another all-time cinema hero doubling down on an earlier argument that– out of all these early-tens films– it’s the poor, helpless, titanically popular AAA IP franchise reboot that needs a fresh look. Excellent Science Fiction Film? Mandatory viewing? Come on.
The original Alien was a stompy monster movie. An absolutely excellent one, but still stompy and monstrous. You may recall that the Xenomorph was called ‘The Big Chap’ in production. Aliens was an even faster and stompier monster movie with a big stompy ending fight between the biggest and stompiest of monsters, and a big stompy robot. Alien 3 tried a thousand ways in a thousand scripts to be something else and failed, with dignity, in a state of heroism. Resurrection was a big stompy monster movie from someone who wanted to make Firefly instead. Prometheus, finally, was just one more big stompy monster movie in the same vein. It’s not great, it can be happily ignored, it’s a sidenote doomed to eventual excommunication from the franchise canon, and that’s okay. Knock it off with the defensive silliness already.
I’d beg people to just like whatever they want and be honest, but that calling seems to disinterest folks. Is what it is, I guess; the next one will pop up soon.